Rent or buy an office printer? How to decide
Buying a printer looks cheaper on the day. Renting looks cheaper on the monthly budget. The right answer depends on how much you print, how much you want to think about your printer, and what happens when it breaks. Here’s how to decide.
What you’re really paying for
The price of the printer is only part of the cost. Over its life, an office printer also costs you:
- Toner and parts. Usually the biggest cost by far, especially for colour.
- Repairs and call-outs. A busy printer will need servicing. Who pays, and how quickly is it fixed?
- Your time. Ordering toner, chasing repairs and dealing with paper jams all take someone away from their real job.
- Downtime. When the only printer in the office stops, quotes, invoices and contracts stop with it.
So the useful question isn’t “what does the printer cost?” It’s “what does each printed page cost, all in?”
When buying makes sense
- You print very little. A few pages a day in a home office or a one-person practice.
- You’re happy to manage it yourself. Ordering toner, booking repairs and replacing it when it dies.
- You have the cash and want to own the asset.
Buying outright can work well here. Just budget for toner and the occasional repair, and expect to replace the printer when it gets old.
When renting makes sense
- You print every day, especially in colour or in larger volumes.
- You want one predictable monthly cost instead of surprise bills for toner and repairs.
- The printer is important to your business, so downtime costs you money.
- You’d rather keep your cash for the business than tie it up in equipment.
- You want newer equipment, with the option to upgrade when your needs change.
With a managed rental, the printer, toner and service usually come together on one agreement, and you pay a known cost per page. Many printers report their own toner levels, so a new cartridge arrives before you run out.
A quick checklist
| Question | If yes, lean towards |
|---|---|
| Do you print more than a few hundred pages a month? | Renting |
| Do you print a lot of colour? | Renting |
| Would a broken printer hold up quotes, invoices or contracts? | Renting |
| Do you want one fixed monthly cost? | Renting |
| Do you print only now and then? | Buying |
| Are you happy to order toner and arrange repairs yourself? | Buying |
A word on tax
How rental payments and purchased equipment are treated for tax depends on your business. Ask your accountant which works better for you before you decide.
Not sure? Work out your real cost per page
The easiest way to decide is to compare what you spend now (toner, repairs and the printer itself) with a fixed monthly fee and a known cost per page. In a free 15-minute print-cost review, we look at what you print and spend now, and show you what it would cost on one fixed monthly fee, with toner and service included. You don’t need to wait for your current contract to end.
Related: Print Solutions · Brother or HP for a small office? · Rent instead of buy
